• ZINARA's administrative expenditure reached 5.4% of revenue against the statutory ceiling of 2.5%
  • The difference represents an estimated US$13.6 million, with the Auditor General qualifying its compliance report
  • Previous audit findings establish a longstanding expenditure problem despite improvements in financial management

Harare- The Zimbabwe National Road Administration has spent more than twice the proportion of revenue permitted by law on administration in 2025, exposing a longstanding compliance problem despite substantial improvements in financial management.

Administrative expenditure reached 5.4% of revenue against the 2.5% ceiling prescribed under the Roads Act, exceeding the statutory limit by 116%. The discrepancy attracted a qualification in the Auditor General's legal and regulatory compliance report, raising fresh scrutiny over the administration of US$469.3 million collected from motorists and other road users during the year.

According to Section 15(d) of the Roads Act [Chapter 13:18], expenditure on salaries, allowances and other expenses of the Road Administration must not exceed 2.5% of Road Fund revenue in any financial year. The provision establishes a statutory restriction on institutional expenditure within a financing system principally intended to support road maintenance.

At ZINARA's annual general meeting in October 2026, finance director Adam Zvandasara disclosed that administrative expenditure had declined from a historical peak of 14% to 5.4%. The reduction demonstrates progress in containing operating expenditure, although the institution continues operating above the limit prescribed by the legislation.

Applying the reported percentages to ZINARA's US$469.3 million collections produces estimated administrative expenditure of US$25.3 million against a statutory equivalent of US$11.7 million. The difference amounts to approximately US$13.6 million, according to Equity Axis calculations, equivalent to 2.9 percentage points of total collections.

The calculation provides an indication of the financial exposure, with the precise monetary excess dependent on the audited Road Fund revenue base and expenditure classifications applied under the Act. It cannot automatically be treated as an amount recoverable from management or an established financial loss.

The Auditor General's qualification gives the matter significance beyond the expenditure ratio. According to disclosures at the annual general meeting, ZINARA's 2025 legal and regulatory compliance report received a qualified opinion because administrative expenditure exceeded the statutory threshold, despite the authority reporting clean financial statement audits.

These audit outcomes address distinct requirements. Financial statements may comply with applicable accounting and reporting standards while particular expenditure arrangements remain inconsistent with legislation governing the institution. ZINARA's improved financial reporting record therefore leaves a separate obligation to resolve the statutory expenditure concern.

The problem has persisted for more than a decade. Historical Auditor General reports identified expenditure above the prescribed limit, including administrative ratios of approximately 9% in 2012 and 6% in 2013. Subsequent audits continued recording breaches, with the 2018 report identifying expenditure of 11% against the 2.5% ceiling and the 2019 report recording 10%.

The recurring findings establish that the compliance problem has survived different operating periods and management arrangements. ZINARA's latest reduction to 5.4% represents a meaningful improvement against historical levels, while the persistence of the audit qualification demonstrates that expenditure controls have not achieved the legal requirement.

Management has linked the difficulty to the expansion of ZINARA's responsibilities beyond its original role as a Road Fund administrator. Revenue collection functions previously performed through other public institutions were progressively transferred to ZINARA, requiring additional personnel, information technology, security, financial management and operational systems.

This expansion introduces an institutional dimension to the compliance problem. The authority now administers a substantially larger revenue collection operation, while Section 15(d) continues prescribing a ceiling originally established for the Road Administration. The distinction between expenditure associated with collecting money and expenditure incurred administering the fund has consequently become central to determining compliance.

At the October meeting, ZINARA disclosed that collection costs accounted for approximately 21% of revenue, equivalent to US$98.6 million when applied to annual collections. These expenses are reported separately from the 5.4% administrative ratio, although their precise accounting treatment requires examination before determining the total institutional cost of revenue mobilisation.

Tolling infrastructure, payment processing, contracted service providers and licensing systems carry costs that differ from conventional administrative expenditure. The statutory assessment depends on the legal classification of these activities, including the treatment of shared personnel and technology functions.

The distinction has direct consequences for resources available to road authorities. ZINARA's revenue increased approximately 28% from US$366.95 million in 2024 to US$469.3 million in 2025, supported by tolling, licensing and other road user charges. The financial benefit of higher collections depends partly on the proportion consumed by revenue mobilisation, administration and existing financial obligations.

Initial disclosures placed 2025 disbursements at approximately US$341.8 million, equivalent to 72.8% of collections, while subsequent reports presented a higher figure. The different amounts require reconciliation to establish direct transfers to road authorities, financing repayments and expenditure associated with tolling infrastructure.

This becomes particularly relevant because the Road Fund's primary statutory purpose concerns maintaining the existing road network. The Department of Roads, local authorities and other designated road authorities implement physical works, while ZINARA administers the financing arrangements. Expenditure controls therefore influence the funds potentially available for distribution.

The estimated US$13.6 million difference against the statutory ceiling is material within this structure. Its significance lies in the opportunity to preserve additional funding through lower administrative expenditure, subject to maintaining effective collection systems and meeting legally authorised operating requirements.

Government has acknowledged the need to resolve the discrepancy. Transport and Infrastructural Development Minister Felix Mhona called for a sustainable solution consistent with the law, while management disclosed engagement with the ministries responsible for transport and finance.

An earlier proposal to amend the Roads Act sought to increase the administrative expenditure ceiling to 15%, with Auditor General reports recording the proposal as being under ministerial consideration. The latest available disclosures continue treating the 2.5% limit as applicable, with no confirmed enacted amendment establishing a replacement ceiling.

The proposed adjustment raises a financial governance issue extending beyond the appropriate percentage. Increasing the ceiling would provide greater flexibility to finance the authority's expanded responsibilities, while also changing the proportion of Road Fund revenue legally available for institutional expenditure. Such a decision requires a transparent assessment of the cost of revenue collection, operational efficiency and the resources necessary for road maintenance.

Equity Axis takes the view that ZINARA's financial reforms have reduced the scale of its administrative expenditure problem, although the statutory compliance issue remains unresolved. The recurring audit findings establish the need for an institutional response supported by a clear expenditure reconciliation and a legally authorised operating framework.

The immediate requirement is disclosure of the detailed administrative cost schedule, including expenditure on salaries, shared services, information technology and collection arrangements. The reconciliation should establish the denominator used in the statutory calculation and the specific expenses responsible for the reported excess.

ZINARA should also provide a measurable compliance timetable and quantify the savings expected from collection contract renegotiations and operational efficiencies. These disclosures would allow Parliament and road users to assess the financial implications of retaining the current statutory ceiling or pursuing legislative changes.

The US$469.3 million collected in 2025 demonstrates ZINARA's growing capacity to mobilise road financing. The outstanding governance issue concerns the cost and legal basis of administering those resources. Resolving the expenditure breach would strengthen the connection between financial management reforms, statutory accountability and funding available for Zimbabwe's road maintenance programme.

Equity Axis News